created by: Rob McElhenney
It has come to my attention that Friday’s edition might have been a bit heavy on the girl-stuff. A chick-lit novel and a young female pop artist were perhaps more than my male readers wanted to take all in one day. To show my impartiality in subject matter, today I will be reviewing one of the most masculine television programs that has ever (dis)graced my DVR. Now before you guys get your boxers in a bunch, hang tight. The (dis) above was not meant as a ‘dis’.
This very nontraditional sit-com revolves around a neighborhood bar in South Philadelphia called Paddy’s Pub and the various miscreants who work there. It airs on the FX network at 10:00 PM on Thursdays. The gang consists of Dennis, Charlie and Mac (co-owners of the bar), Jack Reynolds (Danny DeVito), who owns the land the bar sits on, and Diandra (Dennis’ twin sister and Paddy’s bartender). A group of more dysfunctional, morally corrupt friends we have never seen… all wrapped up with the sense of humor of a 12-year old boy. Although I’ve never been to Philadelphia, I’ve always understood that ‘The City of Brotherly Love’ was said tongue-in-cheek…I hold this show up as evidence.
The show is in its fourth season (somehow I missed the first three…?) and has been renewed for another two, at least. It is tightly written and very well acted. It is smart, while being possibly the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen on television. Do you remember the first time you heard Red call Eric a ‘dumb ass’ on ‘That 70’s Show’? Remember how scandalous it seemed to hear such vile language on television 10 years ago? In a recent episode of ‘Sunny’, the cast used the word ’shit’ probably a half dozen times before the first commercial break. This is very adult (and by adult, please note I do NOT mean mature) programming and is patently unsuitable for children, the elderly, and my mother.
South Park fans will know how that show is unconscionably rude but still has a profound moral underpinning (sometimes?). I toyed with the idea of saying that the moral underpinning here was the gang’s commitment to one another, their fundamental friendship. But on second thought, it occurs to me that I would run screaming from any of these folks as my friends. They are connected, sure…but are often victims of one another in heinous ways.
In last week’s episode ‘Paddy’s Pub: The Worst Bar in Philadelphia’ the gang kidnaps a reviewer who lambastes the bar. This may have contributed, in part, to the slightly negative tone of this review. (Having said that, do you think it makes me slightly crazy that I hope for that kind of success in my reviewing career? You know you’ve arrived when you’re kidnapped…)
In many ways, I’m ‘one of the boys’. Most of my friends are male. My best friend is a lesbian. I can hang with sports, I’m down with Hooters (they do NOT have the best wings, by the way), and I understand and often participate in the games men play. I have made a significant effort to like this show. I seriously committed. The seventh episode this season (entitled ‘Who Pooped The Bed?’) marks my final effort. Charlie and Jack (Danny DeVito) share an apartment and, it turns out, a bed. Someone is pooping the bed and the gang must discover who. At the end of the episode, when the culprit is revealed, he defends his actions by reminding the gang that ‘poop is funny’. Did I mention it helps if you’re a 12 year old boy?
It’s not that it’s a bad show. If you find practical jokes hilarious and want to glean ideas for how to treat your friends badly, this show is for you. If I should happen to be with one of the guys and they want to watch ‘It’s Always Sunny’, I’m in – and they’re gonna want to watch it. Who do you think recommended it to me (Thanks, R)? Even so, on Thursday nights if I’m home alone, I’m tuning back in to ER. It’s the final season. It occasionally makes me feel good about humanity. This is certain to never happen watching ‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’.
Season 1 on iTunes:
© Copyright 2008.
All Rights Reserved. All Wrongs Avenged.
Theodore Roosevelt wrote: ‘It’s not the critic who counts’. His was an ode to the man who does, rather than to the man who sits idly by. Well, Mr. Roosevelt didn’t live in the 21st century, surrounded by 24-hour news media, where ‘multi-tasking’ has evolved past being a Corporate America catch-phrase and is now a life strategy for frazzled soccer moms. We don't have much 'sitting idly' time, and what little we have must be used wisely!